Want to read Slashdot from your mobile device? Point it at m.slashdot.org and keep reading!
Posted by EditorDavid from the I’ll-be-seeing-you dept.
Slashdot reader Applehu Akbar shared this report from MacRumors: Epic Games CEO Tim Sweeney commented on Apple’s ‘Find My’ service, referring to it as “super creepy surveillance tech” that “shouldn’t exist.” Sweeney went on to explain that several years ago, “a kid” stole a Mac laptop out of his car. Years later, Sweeney was checking Find My, and as the Mac was still connected to his Apple ID account, it showed him the location where the thief lived.
When someone asked Sweeney if he’d at least gotten his laptop back, Sweeney answered “No. I was creeped the hell out by having unexpectedly received the kid’s address, and turned off Find My iPhone on all of my devices.”
Slashdot reader crmarvin42 quipped “Tell me you are stupidly rich, without telling me you are stupidly rich… Next someone will be saying that it is ‘Creepy’ to have security footage of someone taking your Amazon packages off of your porch.” And they also questioned Sweeney’s sincerity, suggesting that he’s “just saying that to try and make Apple look bad because of all the lawsuits going on.”
MacRumors followed the ensuing discussion: Sweeney said that the location of a device in someone’s possession can’t be tracked without tracking the person, and “people have a right to privacy.” [“This right applies to second hand device buyers and even to thieves.”] He claims that detection and recovery of a lost or stolen device should be “mediated by due process of law” and not exposed to the device owner “in vigilante fashion.”
Some responded to Sweeney’s comments by sharing the headline of a Vox news story about Epic’s own privacy polices. (“Fortnite maker Epic Games has to pay $520 million for tricking kids and violating their privacy.”)
MacRumors cited a 2014 report that thefts of iPhones dropped after the introduction of Apple’s “Activation Lock” feature (which prevents the disabling of ‘Find My’ without a password).
But when the blog AppleInsider accused Sweeney of “an incredibly bad leap of logic” — Sweeney responded. “You’re idealizing this issue as good guys tracking criminals to their lairs, but when Find My or Google’s similar tech points a device owner to a device possessor’s home, one must anticipate the presence of families and kids and innocent used device buyers, and ask whether it’s really appropriate for a platform to use GPS and shadowy mesh network tech to set up physical confrontations among individuals.”
Sweeney also posted a quote from Steve Jobs about how at Apple, “we worry that some 14-year-old is going to get stalked and something terrible is going to happen because of our phone.”
“A complex system that works is invariably found to have evolved from a simple system that worked.” — John Gall, _Systemantics_
Working…
