Recently, Elon Musk has expressed doubts about the security of the messaging app Signal. This shift in opinion adds more heat to the ongoing debate between Telegram and Signal. The debate is about which app is more secure.
Musk, known for his influence in technology, suggested that Signal has some unresolved security issues, but he did not provide specific details. His comments came shortly after Pavel Durov, CEO of Telegram, criticized Signal’s encryption methods.
Durov claimed that the U.S. government invested money in developing Signal’s encryption and implied that Signal might not be as secure as people think. He mentioned that some users told him their private Signal messages had been used against them, but he did not share further evidence.
In the past, Tucker Carlson, a former Fox News host, also claimed that the NSA had hacked into his Signal account. He made these claims without presenting any proof.
Despite these criticisms, Signal remains a popular choice for secure communication, especially known for its end-to-end encryption and open-source technology. High-profile figures like Jeff Bezos have trusted Signal for private business communications.
The debate intensified with a critical article by Christopher Rufo, who attacked the integrity of Signal’s leadership, specifically targeting Katherine Maher, the chairman of the Signal Foundation. Rufo described Maher as someone who could potentially compromise the app’s trustworthiness, but again, no concrete evidence was presented.
In response to Musk’s tweets, Meredith Whittaker, president of Signal, defended the app. She highlighted Signal’s commitment to privacy and its open source nature. She stated that signal uses strong cryptography to protect your data and has been reliable for over a decade.
Amidst these disputes, Matthew Green, a cryptography professor, warned that Telegram’s campaign to portray Signal as insecure could lead users towards less secure alternatives. He criticized Telegram for not encrypting messages by default, suggesting it could be less safe for users concerned about privacy.
This ongoing dispute has stirred significant discussion in the tech world, with people reconsidering which messaging apps they can trust for secure communication.
Image: Mika Baumeister / unsplash.com
Read next: Google Search Users Opting Out of AI-Generated Results: Traditional Search on the Rise?
